• STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATUREMay 7, 2025
    DR ITUMELENG SEITSHIRO  TECHNICAL ASSISTANT TO THE EXECUTIVE HEAD OF PROJECTS – DEBSWANA  RelatedPosts STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE Modernising the exchange Debswana production down 31% LAGAGO TAMOCHA  “BE yourself; everyone else is already taken” by Oscar Wilde is… Read more: STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE
  • Modernising the exchangeMay 7, 2025
    MASEGO PHETO-LENTSWE  HEAD, CLEARING AND SETTLEMENT  RelatedPosts STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE Modernising the exchange Debswana production down 31% BOTSWANA STOCK EXCHANGE  MASEGO Pheto-Lentswe has built a strong reputation in banking, risk management, and capital markets. With nearly three… Read more: Modernising the exchange
  • Batswana (66%) favour direct election of PresidentMay 5, 2025
    AfroBarometer, ‘a pan-African, non-partisan survey research network that provides reliable data on African experiences and evaluations of democracy, governance, and quality of life’ has released key findings on how the majority of Batswana favour the direct election of their… Read more: Batswana (66%) favour direct election of President
  • The Papacy is not a United Nations seat or a World Cup final!May 5, 2025
    DIMAKATSO MICHELLE POLOKELO  Some people are busy trying to turn the next Papal Election into a competition for hosting of a World Cup Final. “It’s Africa’s turn”, some say, as if the Chair of Peter rotates like the UN… Read more: The Papacy is not a United Nations seat or a World Cup final!
  • Molome takes chargeMay 5, 2025
      Cinderella Monica Molome, the newly elected president of the Botswana National Front Women’s League (BNFWL) is fast at work aiming to transform the BNFWL into a force to reckon with together with her fellow comrades elected into the… Read more: Molome takes charge
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
  • Login
  • Register
Saturday, May 10, 2025
-6 °c
Columbus
6 ° Sat
13 ° Sun
15 ° Mon
16 ° Tue
The Patriot On Sunday
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
Cart / $0.00

No products in the cart.

  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
The Patriot On Sunday
No Result
View All Result
Home Uncategorized

Ministers are flouting the doctrine of collective responsibility

Ricardo Kanono by Ricardo Kanono
March 23, 2021
in Uncategorized
250
0
Modukanele

Modukanele

491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
ShareShareShare

ADAM PHETLHE

In the ongoing debates on Committee of Supply sessions of various ministry budget allocations, some members of the Executive are behaving out of the doctrine of collective responsibility. Put bluntly, they are attacking decisions of the very government they are part of. The doctrine demands that members of the Executive defend such decisions whether they privately agree with them or not, or whether they were or not part of the Executive when such were taken. Assistant Minister of Local Government Hon Setlhabelo Modukanele was scathing on his government when debating the Appropriation (2021/2022) Bill, 2021 (Bill No. 2021) on the Ministry of Health and Wellness during the session held on 17 March 2021 broadcast on Botswana Television. Other members of the Executive whom I watched as well, expressed Hon Modukanele’s views albeit in a somewhat toned down language probably out of fear of the consequences thereto. The Committee of Supply session and seemingly, is the one where fellow cabinet members attack each other softly and roughly out of frustration from the slow progress in their constituencies   

RelatedPosts

346 perish in road mishaps 

Stanbic’s big step to unlock growth

How Asset Declaration Works in Botswana

Visibly incensed by the tone of his input in the Committee of Supply session refereed to above for the lack of a primary hospital in his Lerala/Maunatlala constituency, Hon Modukanele took a serious dig at the construction of two hospitals in Serowe while his constituency had none. He further complained that his constituents are forced to go to seek medical assistance in Palapye which amongst others, is a socio-economic burden on his constituents in more ways than one. On the face of it on one hand, Hon Modukanele is raising pertinent issues regarding his constituency that should go down well with his constituents. On the other, and just like his other fellow members of cabinet, he is criticising the policies of his own government as alluded to above in a frank and open manner if you sit on the other side of the aisle.

Members of cabinet who are also directly elected Members of Parliament, have a duty and obligation to present the concerns and aspirations of their constituents. If they do not do so like other MPs who are not members of the Executive and who by virtue of the Separation of Powers doctrine enjoy the privilege of criticising their own government, they run the risk of being ‘unelectable’ in the 2024 general election because they would be deemed by their constituents not to have sufficiently represented them in parliament. Apart from their own voters, they face the onerous risk of the opposition particularly from marginal constituencies. The heat is palpably unbearable on cabinet members. The other risk is that their appointing authority who is the President, could drop them from their ministerial positions because he may feel they do not defend policies and decisions of cabinet which he chairs. 

The President has been reported in the independent media in the recent past to have sharply raised the concern that he is not sufficiently protected by some members of the Botswana Democratic Party (BDP). His concerns are borne out of the view that the opposition is having a free ride in parliament by sharply criticising him on issues of his private participation in business interests which the opposition argue, border on his unethical and immoral conduct as a Head of State. Instead of protecting the President on these and other issues the arguments posit, some Ministers somewhat take their eyes off the ball by dwelling on the former President and his past policies or style of governing.  If these views are correct, it should go without saying that the President could feel even more concerned if not aggrieved by the ‘open ridiculing’ fashion in parliament by some of his cabinet members over some government policies and programmes. In some way, Hon Modukanele and some of his fellow members could be misconstrued to be helping the opposition to ridicule the policies and programmes of the BDP and in the process, make the BDP look bad in the eyes of the public particularly voters. Needless to mention, the ridicule could be viewed as also directed at the President considering the current political atmosphere.

All policies and programmes of the ruling BDP including developmental agendas I want to believe, are  debated and decided upon during cabinet meetings. That is why Ministers bring their own developmental policies and programmes including budget proposals for their constituencies and others to parliament for endorsement by their fellow MPs. And we have witnessed their fellow party MPs approving and endorsing the budget proposals while at the same time two BDP MPs recently voting with the opposition in one of its Motions. Ministers would have had the opportunity at cabinet to presumably try to influence their own constituency developmental issues even if such moves wouldn’t have carried the day.  My proposition could very well be flawed I must admit. But that is how I personally feel about it. Ministers are fully aware that given their positions in the Executive, things wouldn’t always go their way as would those of other ordinary MPs. When accepting a ministerial positions, they have a duty and obligation to defend decisions taken by their predecessors be they Ministers or Presidents however offensive they may be to them in their private spaces.

What I have observed is that (some) Ministers cheery pick to abide by the doctrine of collective responsibility. All of them have religiously rejected all Motions, Private Members’ Bill and any other parliamentary process brought by the opposition presumably on party caucus direction even when  privately, they may have agreed with them as would be expected while accepting and endorsing all such processes brought by their fellow cabinet members and MPs. 

The current session on Committee of Supply for different ministries may have offered a rare window of opportunity for Ministers to try to speak for their constituencies. In the process, they wittingly or unwittingly, flout the doctrine of collective responsibility to their own detriment and that of the BDP. The minute a cabinet member speaks or is seen to be speaking opposition language of ridiculing the ruling party policies and programmes portrays the ruling party in bad light. Cabinet members are part and parcel of the authority that formulates such policies and programmes and for them to be acting contrary to such authority is nothing less than political suicide. In the backdrop of the alleged President’s dissatisfaction that his party fellows are not protecting him from the opposition onslaught in parliament and from other ordinary members of society, it may not look good for those Ministers and Assistant Ministers who may be viewed as flouting the said doctrine and in the process, bringing their party into disrepute. Only time will tell. I am prepared to be persuaded otherwise as always. Judge for Yourself!

Covid-19 pandemic has now taken a turn for the worse. Let us up our game of complying with all health protocols. It is our civic duty and obligation to do so.

adamphetlhe08@gmail.com   

Related

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Masisi’s error of judgment

Next Post

In times likes these we need a saviour

Related Posts

346 perish in road mishaps 
Uncategorized

346 perish in road mishaps 

April 3, 2025
Stanbic’s big step to unlock growth
Uncategorized

Stanbic’s big step to unlock growth

March 21, 2025
How Asset Declaration Works in Botswana
Uncategorized

How Asset Declaration Works in Botswana

March 6, 2025
Botswana’s economic growth slows to 1% in 2024 -IMF 
Business

Botswana’s economic growth slows to 1% in 2024 -IMF 

July 25, 2024
Botswana student ranked top in accounting globally 
News

Botswana student ranked top in accounting globally 

July 3, 2024
UDC IMPLODING UNDER BOKO’S WATCH
News

UDC IMPLODING UNDER BOKO’S WATCH

June 13, 2024
Next Post
In times likes these we need a saviour

In times likes these we need a saviour

Please login to join discussion
  • STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATUREMay 7, 2025
    DR ITUMELENG SEITSHIRO  TECHNICAL ASSISTANT TO THE EXECUTIVE HEAD OF PROJECTS – DEBSWANA  RelatedPosts STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE Modernising the exchange Debswana production down 31% LAGAGO TAMOCHA  “BE yourself; everyone else is already taken” by Oscar Wilde is… Read more: STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE
  • Modernising the exchangeMay 7, 2025
    MASEGO PHETO-LENTSWE  HEAD, CLEARING AND SETTLEMENT  RelatedPosts STRONG, FOCUSED FORCE OF NATURE Modernising the exchange Debswana production down 31% BOTSWANA STOCK EXCHANGE  MASEGO Pheto-Lentswe has built a strong reputation in banking, risk management, and capital markets. With nearly three… Read more: Modernising the exchange
  • Batswana (66%) favour direct election of PresidentMay 5, 2025
    AfroBarometer, ‘a pan-African, non-partisan survey research network that provides reliable data on African experiences and evaluations of democracy, governance, and quality of life’ has released key findings on how the majority of Batswana favour the direct election of their… Read more: Batswana (66%) favour direct election of President
  • The Papacy is not a United Nations seat or a World Cup final!May 5, 2025
    DIMAKATSO MICHELLE POLOKELO  Some people are busy trying to turn the next Papal Election into a competition for hosting of a World Cup Final. “It’s Africa’s turn”, some say, as if the Chair of Peter rotates like the UN… Read more: The Papacy is not a United Nations seat or a World Cup final!
  • Molome takes chargeMay 5, 2025
      Cinderella Monica Molome, the newly elected president of the Botswana National Front Women’s League (BNFWL) is fast at work aiming to transform the BNFWL into a force to reckon with together with her fellow comrades elected into the… Read more: Molome takes charge
The Patriot On Sunday

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?