Following a thoughtful and objective deliberation on the need, significance and implications of extending the ‘ongoing six months State of Public Emergency (SOPE) due to lapse in a few weeks, Botswana Federation of Trade Unions (BFTU) and the Botswana Federation of Public Sector Unions (BOFEPUSU) hereby jointly submit their position and proposals on the way forward as follows;
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β We note the Government’s prompt response to the threat posed by the covid-19 pandemic through instituting a range of measures including among others, the imposition of lockdowns, and border closures, and the shutdown of social and economic activities.
β’ We further note that this intervention is worth acknowledging and commendable, both for its swiftness and thorough-going effect as it sent out a clear and loud message to the public, authorities and the world about the seriousness with which we regard the danger presented by the disease. It is worth stating that a great deal of awareness was achieved in this one fell swoop albeit the harder way.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β As theΒ Β two federations, we acknowledge the COVIODΒ Β – 19Β Β preventative measures that wereΒ Β instituted byΒ Β government and probably byΒ Β equal measure much was learnt by the public about the importance of social distancingΒ Β andΒ Β theΒ Β significance ofΒ Β Β hygiene asΒ Β partΒ Β ofΒ Β Β preventive regimen.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β WeΒ Β Β observeΒ Β howeverΒ Β thatΒ Β Β owmgΒ Β toΒ Β Β theΒ Β StateΒ Β ofΒ Β Β Emergency and accompanying social and economic restrictions, the economy became subdued andΒ Β hasΒ Β been, muchΒ Β toΒ Β Β theΒ Β Β acknowledgement ofΒ Β experts, badly hitΒ Β Β duringΒ Β theΒ Β SOPE.Β It is common knowledge that there was complete shutdownΒ Β ofΒ Β industriesΒ Β including, butΒ Β notΒ Β Β limitedΒ Β toΒ Β Β the alcohol industry,Β Β sports,Β Β entertainment,Β Β hotel &Β Β hospitalityΒ Β andΒ Β on occasiOns, theΒ Β all-important transport industry as wellΒ Β as centres ofΒ learning.
β’ We note further that the livelihoods of ordinary citizens were relegated to second place in consideration of the broader scheme of things. The obvious consequence to this has been the low turnout on income tax as well as the exacerbation of poverty levels among the ordinary Batswana. Government’s income tax will as a matter of fact take a knock for the next fiscal year.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β WeΒ Β noteΒ Β Β withΒ Β Β regret asΒ Β theΒ Β Β twoΒ Β labour centres that . whilstΒ Β itΒ Β was categorically pronounced andΒ Β further stipulatedΒ by theΒ Β regulations governing theΒ Β SOPE,Β Β that noΒ Β retrenchments orΒ Β termination ofΒ employment shall ensue as aΒ Β result ofΒ Β theΒ Β Β SOPE,Β Β Β inΒ Β reality many workers wereΒ Β left inΒ Β theΒ Β lurch without much recourse forΒ Β anyΒ Β formΒ Β of assistance.
β’ We also note, with deep regret, that the working class and the informal economy have drastically lost their sources of livelihoods due to reduced or no earnings at all.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β We further noteΒ Β that during theΒ Β SOPE,Β Β theΒ Β working class sufferedΒ inΒ an unprecedented manner as a result of their earnings beingΒ Β cutΒ Β down byΒ chunks, inΒ Β someΒ Β instances as huge as 60%Β Β of their salaries, being forcedΒ Β toΒ take unpaid and forcedΒ Β paidΒ Β leaves.
β’ The above, no doubt has resulted in a lot of the working class facing challenges in repaying loans they secured during their working times, paying rents, school fees and even struggling to afford to buy the basic necessities to meet their daily needs.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β AsΒ Β ifΒ Β that wasΒ Β Β notΒ Β Β enough,Β Β flagrantΒ Β escalationΒ Β ofΒ Β pricesΒ Β of commodities such as basic foodΒ Β items, transport,Β electricityΒ and fuel only compounded the worker’s dilemma.
β’ One of the clear-cut provisions of the SOPE regulations was to ban any strikes by workers. The import of this was to strip the workers and their representative organizations of any bargaining power during these hard times and as a consequence, employers took advantage and blatantly scaled down working conditions, and in many instances, out rightly flouting laws governing industrial relations. Bluntly stated and simply put, the SOPE helped perpetuate lawlessness in the world of work.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β InΒ Β Β Β summingΒ Β upΒ Β Β allΒ Β Β Β issuesΒ Β Β andΒ Β Β factoringΒ Β eachΒ Β Β mΒ Β Β Β our considerationΒ Β ofΒ Β theΒ Β benefits andΒ Β theΒ Β Β downsideΒ Β ofΒ Β theΒ Β SOPE, we strongly hold thatΒ Β little was achieved inΒ Β Β terms ofΒ Β the keyΒ Β Β reasons presented before the national assembly as the basis forΒ Β proposing the enactment of theΒ Β SOPE.
β’ For example, in motivating the motion for the SOPE government cited the need to mobilize resources to purchase medical requisites and equipment. Ironically though, vast numbers of frontline workers remain exposed and vulnerable to infection because none such special powers as provided by SOPE regulations were ever evoked.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β BFTUΒ Β Β Β andΒ Β Β BOFEPUSU believeΒ Β thatΒ Β Β Β asΒ Β Β representativesΒ Β Β and spokespersonsΒ Β ofΒ Β Β aΒ Β wideΒ Β Β Β andΒ Β largeΒ Β spectrumΒ Β ofΒ Β Β theΒ Β Β Β working-classΒ movement and as a critical component ofΒ Β theΒ civilΒ Β society movement in Botswana, weΒ Β have a shared responsibility toΒ Β safeguard the democratic space of this country. Failure to provide this ingredient creates a risk of feeding into theΒ Β Β narrative that the SOPE isΒ Β calculated toΒ Β cover ulterior political agendas.
β’ We must hasten to acknowledge our realization that there is a notable spike in the number or statistics of infections. We however submit that the existing Public Health Act provisions, especially Part III, Section 18 enables the Director of Public Health to appropriately and timeously invoke relevant provisions to respond proportionately to the dictates of the situation rather than by way of unnecessary blanket disruption to social, political and many other spheres of public life.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β AnyΒ Β other approach carries potential toΒ Β ferment otherwise avoidable dissent.
β’ We contend that in the absence of a genume, transparent and thorough evaluative report showing the effectiveness or otherwise of the past months of SOPE to this point, we cannot find any justifiable basis for supporting a further extension of the State of Public Emergency.
β’Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β It is inΒ Β this same context that we hold that whilst it may notΒ Β be easy toΒ Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β substantiateΒ Β Β allegationsΒ Β ofΒ Β Β corruptΒ Β practicesΒ Β byΒ Β Β government officials and members of theΒ Β executive it appears there is reasonable cause toΒ Β suspectΒ Β thatΒ Β officials have usedΒ Β loopholes inΒ Β Β theΒ Β Β system duringΒ Β theΒ Β Β SOPEΒ Β toΒ Β appropriateΒ Β toΒ Β Β themselves, friends andΒ Β their relativesΒ Β resourcesΒ Β Β belongingΒ Β toΒ Β Β theΒ Β Β Β publicΒ Β byΒ Β Β wayΒ Β Β Β ofΒ Β Β “special procurement processes”. ItΒ Β would therefore beΒ Β inΒ Β theΒ Β Β public interest and transparency toΒ Β dispel any furtherΒ Β misperceptions around this type of procurement processes.
β’ Finally, extending the SOPE may lead to a total collapse of what remains of our industry and a further massive loss of employment with disastrous social and political outcomes for the country.
β’ Our position is therefore a clear–No to the extension of SOPE.