• Wellness Concierge Therapist: BotswanaMay 13, 2025
    RelatedPosts Wellness Concierge Therapist: Botswana Job Opportunity Vacancy
  • The sham that was BNFWL elective congressMay 13, 2025
    As if not to be outdone by the Botswana Democratic Party (BDP) chaotic bulela ditswe on the eve of the 2024 general election which process is credited with contributing in no small measure to the demise of the BDP,… Read more: The sham that was BNFWL elective congress
  • Khama pokes MotshegwaMay 13, 2025
      Convenes meeting in Mmadinare kgotla, Motshegwa’s home village ‘I am not into politics’ – Khama denies ignoring govt directive Motshegwa mum on Khama’s meetings BAKANG TIRO RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Stanbic boosts green economy Europe Day 2025 –… Read more: Khama pokes Motshegwa
  • Stanbic boosts green economyMay 12, 2025
    As Stanbic, GIZ strategically collaborate GIZ PDP blueprint to strengthen market development Stanbic upbeat, keen on greening of the economy Combating Climate Change core focus BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Stanbic boosts green economy BDP ‘rapes’ Constitution… Read more: Stanbic boosts green economy
  • Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and SolidarityMay 12, 2025
    PETRA PETEYRA The EU Ambassador to Botswana, SADC RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity BDP ‘rapes’ Constitution   Thank you for joining us today to celebrate Europe Day. The 9th… Read more: Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
  • Login
  • Register
Wednesday, May 14, 2025
17 °c
Gaborone
21 ° Tue
22 ° Wed
24 ° Thu
26 ° Fri
The Patriot On Sunday
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
Cart / $0.00

No products in the cart.

  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
The Patriot On Sunday
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis & Opinions

Skelemani was harsh and unreasonable in suspending Saleshando

patriot by patriot
December 13, 2020
in Analysis & Opinions
250
0
491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
ShareShareShare

Since the live broadcasting of Parliamentary proceedings from Boipuso hall, I have been giving the Speaker of the National Assembly Rre Phandu Skelemani the full marks on how he demonstrated fairness, tolerance, impartiality completed by his rich sense of humour. But not until Monday 27 July 2020 when all these attributes seemed to desert him. He is also human like all of us. But Rre Skelemani is no ordinary human being. He brought to the Speakership and the National Assembly, glorious years of high levels of experience as a public servant grounded in law and as a politician. With respect to the National Assembly, he graced its benches long before he became a duly elected Member of Parliament. Consequently, he would have known how politicians behave and the requisite but restrained measures the Speaker resorts to. But lo and behold. Monday and Tuesday were completely different days.

Hon Dumelang Saleshando was suspended by the Speaker for refusing to withdraw his complaint that the President’s sister had acquired a fraudulent tender at the beginning of the Covid-19 period. At issue was the fact that the Speaker felt Hon Saleshando had not provided him with the evidence that linked the sister to the President in the said complaint. By any measure, failure to provide such evidence and trivial as it is in my view, wouldn’t be considered a refusal by Hon Saleshando to obey the Speaker’s instruction which consequently could result in a suspension. I am saying trivial in that at that stage, parliament was not even seized with investigating the alleged fraudulent nature of the tender to the President’s ‘disputed’ family relationship to the sister. That evidence therefore would be imperative once the investigation was truly under investigation by the competent and relevant institution. The suspension would be warranted and appropriate if during the exchanges between them, Hon Saleshando used un-parliamentary language, was demonstrably rude and disorderly to the Speaker. None of such conduct remotely or otherwise, was demonstrable on the two days of back and forth which could be attributable to the MP. Not by any means.

RelatedPosts

The sham that was BNFWL elective congress

Batswana (66%) favour direct election of President

Khama in crosshairs of BCL inquiry

The suspension was pronounced by the Speaker on the Monday when Hon Saleshando’s matter was brought to the parliament floor. On that day, the Speaker did not cause the effect of the said suspension by specifically asking him to leave parliament. Instead, he said that given that the exchanges may have been at the heat of the moment, he gave Hon Saleshando the chance to reflect on the matter overnight presumably to come back the next with a changed position of withdrawing his complaint. At this stage, it appeared apparent that neither the Speaker nor Hon Saleshando would change their positions. That is, the Speaker was resolute in his suspension owing to what some say was political pressure from the majority party while Hon Saleshando was resolute as well in refusing to withdraw his complaint as requested by the Speaker. I am yet to understand why the process of naming the suspended MP as it emerged on Tuesday; the involvement of the two Chief Whips to move or oppose the actual passing of the suspension motion and others, was not implemented on the very day the suspension was pronounced by the Speaker.   

Parliament rules generally speaking it is said, provide that a Member of Parliament could be suspended from its proceedings when such member ‘Persistently and wilfully obstruct the House; used objectionable words which she/he has refused to withdraw; persistently and wilfully refused to conform to a Standing Order; wishfully disobeyed an order of the House; persistently and wilfully disregarded the authority of the Speaker and, has been considered by the Speaker to have behaved in a disorderly manner.’ Do the foregoing apply with respect of Hon Saleshando even if suspension was appropriate? Not at all because he had neither misbehaved in the remotest possibility nor committed contempt of parliament let alone to the Speaker. So in so far as the generality and the specificity of suspending a Member of Parliament as indicated in the above quote is concerned, Hon Saleshando was harshly and unreasonably suspended from the House. And the action of the Speaker has set a very bad and dangrous precedent in the House.

It tells me that the Speaker is curtailing the objective participation of Members of Parliament in pursuing bothering national issues and in this case the corruption issue. While it is not good for MPs to hide behind parliamentary privilege to malign private citizens, nothing suggests for now that Hon Saleshando had any ulterior motives to name the President’s sister to have fraudulently obtained a tender. And this is because his complaint has not yet been tested to establish its veracity or lack thereof. Is there any legal or other basis upon which the Speaker should have suspended Hon Saleshando?

The answer could be located in the statement issued by the Botswana Movement for Democracy (BMD) President Advocate Sidney Pilane. He says that the Constitution of Botswana which has created parliament which MPs are part of, does not give it power to suspend an MP, ‘certainly not an elected one…. Our parliament must not arrogate itself powers it does not have. Unlike in other jurisdictions, the Parliament of Botswana is not supreme. Like all of us, it is subject to the Constitution. Parliament is a creature of statute, the Constitution, and the limits of its powers are to be found within the four walls of that hallowed document.’ Advocate Pilane’s view is ably supported by the decision of the South African Supreme Court of Appeal judgement case No 279/98 in the matter between The Speaker of the National Assembly (Appellant), Patricia De Lille (First Responded) and Pan Africanist Congress of Azania (Second Respondent).

The crux of the matter in this case briefly is that De Lille was suspended by the Speaker who had ruled that she had used un-parliamentary language against others specifically ANC members by referring to them as spies. De Lille was asked to apologise and withdraw the remark which she did unconditionally. What was to follow was that parliament sought to punish her by suspending her for 15 days.  Court held that ‘The threat that a member of the Assembly may be suspended for something said in the Assembly inhibits freedom of expression….The right of free speech in the Assembly protected by Section 58 (1) is a fundamental right crucial to representative government in a democratic society. Its tenor and spirit must conform to all other provisions of the Constitution relevant to the conduct of proceedings in Parliament. Part 3 of the Supreme Court of Appeal order was that ‘It is declared that that part of the resolution of the National Assembly adopted on the 25 November 1997 which purports to suspend Mrs Patricia De Lille is void and is set aside.’ Probably telling is part of the judgement that held that ‘No Parliament, however bona fide or eminent its membership, no President, however formidable be his reputation or scholarship and no official, however efficient or well meaning, can make any law or perform any act which is not sanctioned by the Constitution.’ Because I am adamant that Hon Saleshando was harshly and unreasonably treated by the Speaker, I am happy that he is challenging his suspension in court.

In conclusion and all things considered, the Speaker of the National Assembly was harsh and unreasonable in suspending Hon Saleshando. I hold the same view even if a majority party MP was treated in this fashion. He did not behave in any disorderly manner consistent with any reasonable sanction to be removed from parliament. It is disturbing that the Speaker seems to be entering a phase of his word or the highway. It must be accepted that while the Speaker is charged with ensuring the decorum of the House through enforcing discipline amongst others, it doesn’t mean that this equates to dictatorial tendencies as suggested by some. The issue of doubt in his mind that Hon Saleshando failed to establish the relationship of the President to the person referred to as his sister in his allegations is trivial and disappointing as I have said above. The Speaker cannot be allowed to curtail the rights of MPs as contained in the Bill of Rights of the Constitution. I am prepared to be persuaded otherwise as always. Judge for Yourself!

The Covid-19 Presidential Task Force is reporting that the pandemic is taking a turn for the worse. Health protocols are our best defence. Wash your hands with clean water and soap more frequently, keep social distancing and wear your masks. Our destiny is in our own hands. 

adamphetlhe08@gmail.com       

Related

Tags: Skelemani

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Concerns over Makwala Sports Complex location

Next Post

THE CORRUPT MORIBUND BDP AND THE SIMPLE MINDED BDP VOTER

Related Posts

The sham that was BNFWL elective congress
Analysis & Opinions

The sham that was BNFWL elective congress

May 13, 2025
Batswana (66%) favour direct election of President
Analysis & Opinions

Batswana (66%) favour direct election of President

May 5, 2025
Khama in crosshairs of BCL inquiry
Analysis & Opinions

Khama in crosshairs of BCL inquiry

April 29, 2025
Listen to the doctors!
Analysis & Opinions

Listen to the doctors!

April 28, 2025
Fasten your seatbelts, the rough ride unfolds! 
Analysis & Opinions

Fasten your seatbelts, the rough ride unfolds! 

April 15, 2025
Will Dikoloti join UDC or contest 2029 as mokoko?
Analysis & Opinions

Will Dikoloti join UDC or contest 2029 as mokoko?

April 9, 2025
Next Post
THE CORRUPT MORIBUND BDP AND THE SIMPLE MINDED BDP VOTER

THE CORRUPT MORIBUND BDP AND THE SIMPLE MINDED BDP VOTER

Please login to join discussion
  • Wellness Concierge Therapist: BotswanaMay 13, 2025
    RelatedPosts Wellness Concierge Therapist: Botswana Job Opportunity Vacancy
  • The sham that was BNFWL elective congressMay 13, 2025
    As if not to be outdone by the Botswana Democratic Party (BDP) chaotic bulela ditswe on the eve of the 2024 general election which process is credited with contributing in no small measure to the demise of the BDP,… Read more: The sham that was BNFWL elective congress
  • Khama pokes MotshegwaMay 13, 2025
      Convenes meeting in Mmadinare kgotla, Motshegwa’s home village ‘I am not into politics’ – Khama denies ignoring govt directive Motshegwa mum on Khama’s meetings BAKANG TIRO RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Stanbic boosts green economy Europe Day 2025 –… Read more: Khama pokes Motshegwa
  • Stanbic boosts green economyMay 12, 2025
    As Stanbic, GIZ strategically collaborate GIZ PDP blueprint to strengthen market development Stanbic upbeat, keen on greening of the economy Combating Climate Change core focus BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Stanbic boosts green economy BDP ‘rapes’ Constitution… Read more: Stanbic boosts green economy
  • Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and SolidarityMay 12, 2025
    PETRA PETEYRA The EU Ambassador to Botswana, SADC RelatedPosts Khama pokes Motshegwa Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity BDP ‘rapes’ Constitution   Thank you for joining us today to celebrate Europe Day. The 9th… Read more: Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity
The Patriot On Sunday

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?