Cover for The Patriot on Sunday
214,346
The Patriot on Sunday

The Patriot on Sunday

A Sunday broadsheet newspaper that focuses on business and politics. It started publishing on Sunday

The Patriot on Sunday

2 hours ago

The Patriot on Sunday
#businessfrontpagethisweek 🔴 HEADLINE: BoB's XMAS GIFT TO BORROWERS . Bank rate slashed by 25 basis points to 2.4% . Rate has been maintained at 2.65% for a year . Household debt wont subside -economist FOR A DETAILED REPORT GRAB A COPY OF THE PATRIOT ON SUNDAY NEWSPAPER IN STORES OR FOR SUBSCRIPTION VISIT: www.thepatriot.co.bw ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Patriot on Sunday

2 hours ago

The Patriot on Sunday
KNOW YOUR CORPORATE LEADERFull Name: Obakeng Gaebepe Position: Human Resource Manager Institution: Old Mutual Botswana Date Started: May 2018Nature of business: Insurance ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Patriot on Sunday

13 hours ago

The Patriot on Sunday
BLLAHWU SG KETLHALEFILE MOTSHEGWA ELECTED AT WFTU CONGRESS ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Patriot on Sunday

2 days ago

The Patriot on Sunday
MIKE MOTHIBI AT HIS FINAL RESTING PLACEMultitudes of people attended Veteran journalist Mike Mothibi's funeral in Kanye this morning, with speakers proclaiming the good hard working man he was.He leaves behind three children, one boy and two girls and six siblings - four brothers and two sisters. ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Patriot on Sunday

2 days ago

The Patriot on Sunday
Who will be on the Court of Appeal bench to hear & determine IEC appeal against UDC? *ADAM PHETLHE It is generally agreed that the case between Umbrella for Democratic Change (UDC) and the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) is that of exceptional public importance. As a consequence, the case has so far generated a lot of public interest in terms of looking at all its optics. I predict exceptional public interest will continue way beyond the conclusion of the case. So who amongst the present Justices of Appeal will make the cut? It is difficult to say with a measure of certainty who will make the cut but to predict. Depending on the number of Justices required for this expedited appeal, I predict the following to make the cut. Justices Tebogo Tau, Isaac Lesetedi, Mercy Garekwe, Lackvinder Singh & Leatile Dambe. Former South Africa Constititional Court Justice Bess Nkabinde could also make the cut. All the above local Justices have sat on the bench in high profile cases notably last year's DIS appeal with respect to the search warrant for State House 4, the 'contested' official residence of former President Khama. In this case where there were 5 Justices, Justices Tau, Lesetedi & Singh ruled against the DIS while Justices Garekwe & Dambe dissented. It is my belief that Justices decide matters based on what evidence/facts are before them. That some ruled this or the other way in previous cases is, for lack of a better word, inconsequential. The Chief Justice has sat on some appeal cases I have had sight of. I think he will be disqualified in this one because he is party to an application on another leg of the UDC/IEC case. It will be interesting to see if Justice Tau will make the cut owing to a comment she made when delivering judgement on Wednesday with respect to IEC's request to have its appeal expedited. That comment (and I am paraphrasing) had to do with the intrusive nature UDC’s observers would cause if allowed to observe & monitor voter registration exercise. I believe this comment has already rendered her conflicted to sit in the upcoming appeal proceedings. Time will tell as to who will be on the bench when the appeal proceedings begin on Monday 11 December 2023. Or, will it be new faces? ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

  • Towards a Brighter Tomorrow: India’s G20 Presidency and the Dawn of a New MultilateralismNovember 30, 2023
    Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi Today marks 365 days since India assumed the G20 Presidency. It is a moment to reflect, recommit, and rejuvenate the spirit of ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, ‘One Earth, One Family, One Future.’ As we undertook… Read more: Towards a Brighter Tomorrow: India’s G20 Presidency and the Dawn of a New Multilateralism
  • BNF get 15 UDC constituencies November 29, 2023
    BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw The first phase of constituency allocation between Umbrella for Democratic Change (UDC) and its negotiating parties, Botswana Patriotic Front (BPF) and Alliance for Progressives (AP) has seen Botswana National Front (BNF) emerging as the biggest winner… Read more: BNF get 15 UDC constituencies 
  • BHP launches Tshireletso StudyNovember 28, 2023
    . Long-Acting Injectable Cabotegravir for HIV prevention in newly delivered mothers in Botswana The Botswana Harvard Health Partnership (BHP) has today launched the ‘Tshireletso’ Study which is offering long-acting injectable cabotegravir (CAB-LA) to post-partum women immediately after delivery to… Read more: BHP launches Tshireletso Study
  • Orange Botswana CEO, Nene Maïga, Wins Female Innovator of the Year Award November 24, 2023
    Orange Botswana celebrates the business’ CEO, Nene Maïga, on her prestigious Female Innovator of the Year Award 2023, received at the Africa Tech Festival Awards in Cape Town, South Africa. This distinguished accolade recognises the exceptional contributions of women in the fields of technology, media, and telecommunications… Read more: Orange Botswana CEO, Nene Maïga, Wins Female Innovator of the Year Award 
  • Govt’s P1.4billion Tati land headacheNovember 23, 2023
    BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw The 45 000 hectares of land recently acquired by Botswana government from Tati Company to the tune of P1.4 billion, will address acute land shortage in Northeast district, the Minister of Lands and Water Affairs (ML&WA),… Read more: Govt’s P1.4billion Tati land headache
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
  • Login
  • Register
Monday, December 11, 2023
17 °c
Gaborone
21 ° Tue
22 ° Wed
24 ° Thu
26 ° Fri
The Patriot On Sunday
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
Cart / $0.00

No products in the cart.

  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
The Patriot On Sunday
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis & Opinions

Majority judgements give IEC a carte blanche to run elections

patriot by patriot
December 11, 2020
in Analysis & Opinions
247
0
491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
ShareShareShare

The majority judgement of Justices Omphemetse Motumise and Itumeleng Segopolo in the election petitions launched as a result of elections in the Mmashoro and Kaudwane/Sorilatholo wards has somewhat given the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) a carte blanche to run elections in this country. Further to this, the IEC will be buoyed by Section 140 of the Electoral Act which reads in part that “No election shall be set aside by the High Court by reason of any mistake or non-compliance….if it appears to the Court that the election was conducted in accordance with the principles laid down….and that such mistakes or non-compliance did not affect the result of the election.”  Effectively, Section 140 through the majority judgements says to the IEC: you are allowed to commit mistakes such as non-compliance with the Electoral Act in whatever form or shape but kindly ensure that such do not affect the result of the election because if you do so, no court will fault you. Because the issue of ballot papers is in dispute in the two council petitions, I will deal with them  interchangeably in this conversation.    

Justices Motumise and Segopolo appear to be grounding their majority judgement on Section 140 of the Electoral Act as alluded to above. But could the Judges reasonably conclude that the elections at the two council wards were conducted in accordance with the contemplated principles of the Electoral Act? I beg to differ. For example, if the returning officer was called to give evidence, he/she would have told the court if they had complied with Section 71 (4) of the Electoral Act under Method of Counting which provides that “If any candidate or counting agent objects to a decision made by the returning officer….the returning officer shall endorse the words ‘objected to’ on the ballot paper.”  This point was raised by the dissenting judgement of Justice Ketlogetswe in which I suppose these words were not endorsed in the disputed ballot papers. As it is, the matter of how spoiled ballot papers was handled from the IEC perspective remains a matter of speculation because like I have already said, the IEC has failed to take the court in its confidence by not calling the returning officers. The majority Judges seem comfortable with this state of affairs presumably under the reasoning that the issue is too small to have affected the result of the election.   

The issue of the status of ballot papers did not end as articulated above. In elections generally speaking, there are those ballot papers referred to as spoiled. The Free Dictionary defines a spoiled ballot paper as the one that is ‘invalid because the person voting has not marked it properly, whether inadvertently or deliberately.’ If this definition is accepted in the context of the ballot paper issue in these petitions, it is at variance with the majority judgement. The majority judgement contents that it doesn’t matter how the voter voted. What is important according to it, is that the voter would have indicated his/her preferred party by placing any mark wherever and however on the ballot paper as long as there can be a link between the mark and the party. Through this judgement I argue, a spoiled ballot paper particularly in this regard will no longer be in the vocabulary of elections in Botswana because any voter can now decide how he/she decides to vote irrespective of the IEC pronouncements or directions on how and where voters should place the X mark on the ballot paper. It cannot be and it shouldn’t be. A spoiled ballot paper I suppose and in the context of the majority judgements, will only be the one that has two markings on two political party symbols.      

The IEC during its campaigns to teach voters about putting an X mark at the allocated column on the ballot paper, seems not to worry the two Judges. A properly filled ballot paper and an un-properly filled one was demonstrated through IEC campaign bill boards and other fora.  It is accepted that some of the voters may have not marked their ballot papers correctly as would be desirable for one reason or the other. But for the Judges to suggest that any X mark placed elsewhere on the ballot paper or any other mark so placed for that matter shows the intention of the voter borders with the greatest of respect to the learned Judges, on conjecture of some sort. Lawyers including Judges always tell us that ignorance of the law is no excuse. For the two Judges to turn around this time around to insinuate that questionable ballot papers fit enough to be declared spoiled are valid and that ignorance of the law in this regard is an excuse is very unfortunate and disturbing.                             

In the other election petition (Kaudwane/Sorilatholo council ward) concluded by the High Court this past Thursday, Justices Motumise and Segopolo continued to give the IEC a carte blanche to run elections in this country. At the heart of this election petition is the fact that the IEC caused the ballot paper in this ward to include a political party (Alliance for Progressives) not duly nominated to partake in such election.  And the predictable excuse from the two Judges is that such a defective ballot paper did not affect the result. The IEC has played double standards in so far as defective ballot papers are concerned. During the general elections, it was discovered in the Mahalapye East constituency that there was a defective council candidate ballot paper whereupon the IEC itself decided and correctly so in my view, to call off the elections for council candidates. On the same day in the Kaudwane/Sorilatholo council candidate election process, a defective ballot paper was discovered and brought to the attention of the IEC. Unlike in Mahalapye East, the IEC decided to continue with the election. If such a glaring illegality can be entertained by the court on the basis that it did not affect the result of an election, it should reason that no other illegality regarding a defective ballot paper will be outlawed in Botswana elections.        

In conclusion, I hold the view that the majority judgements in the two council election petitions by Justice Omphemetse Motumise and Justice Itumeleng Segopolo have given the IEC a blank cheque to run elections in Botswana. Like I have stated above, the IEC is permitted through these judgements to commit a mistake in the form of non-compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Act only if such mistake or non-compliance do not affect the result of the election. Through these judgement as well, it is reasonable to conclude that voters now and henceforth, are permitted to place any mark on the ballot paper anyhow as long as it can, by inference, be concluded which party the voter intended to vote for. The IEC is further permitted to conduct sham elections by printing defective ballot papers with the full knowledge that any election petition arising therefrom, will be dismissed with costs by the High Court. I am waiting to see what type of voter education the IEC will conduct towards the 2024 general elections. Is it going to say: put your X mark on the designated slot on the ballot paper as it has done so in the past or, put whatever mark on the party symbols in view of the majority judgement ruling? I will also be waiting to see how it will describe a spoilt ballot paper to the voters. 

As a parting shot, I want to believe that Botswana elections will be premised on the end result in that election results will be the most preferred method of determining election petitions than the core imperatives of integrity, credibility and legitimacy of the elections themselves. Whatever processes and principles contemplated in the Electoral Act as prerequisites to deliver a free, fair and credible elections, such will just be an administrative routine akin to an oath of office that subsequently becomes meaningless. Botswana general elections and on the face of the majority judgements, are still poised to be a sham of Biblical proportions. I am prepared to be persuaded otherwise as always. Judge for Yourself!

adamphetlhe08@gmail.com

Related

Tags: IEC

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
  • Towards a Brighter Tomorrow: India’s G20 Presidency and the Dawn of a New MultilateralismNovember 30, 2023
    Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi Today marks 365 days since India assumed the G20 Presidency. It is a moment to reflect, recommit, and rejuvenate the spirit of ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, ‘One Earth, One Family, One Future.’ As we undertook… Read more: Towards a Brighter Tomorrow: India’s G20 Presidency and the Dawn of a New Multilateralism
  • BNF get 15 UDC constituencies November 29, 2023
    BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw The first phase of constituency allocation between Umbrella for Democratic Change (UDC) and its negotiating parties, Botswana Patriotic Front (BPF) and Alliance for Progressives (AP) has seen Botswana National Front (BNF) emerging as the biggest winner… Read more: BNF get 15 UDC constituencies 
  • BHP launches Tshireletso StudyNovember 28, 2023
    . Long-Acting Injectable Cabotegravir for HIV prevention in newly delivered mothers in Botswana The Botswana Harvard Health Partnership (BHP) has today launched the ‘Tshireletso’ Study which is offering long-acting injectable cabotegravir (CAB-LA) to post-partum women immediately after delivery to… Read more: BHP launches Tshireletso Study
  • Orange Botswana CEO, Nene Maïga, Wins Female Innovator of the Year Award November 24, 2023
    Orange Botswana celebrates the business’ CEO, Nene Maïga, on her prestigious Female Innovator of the Year Award 2023, received at the Africa Tech Festival Awards in Cape Town, South Africa. This distinguished accolade recognises the exceptional contributions of women in the fields of technology, media, and telecommunications… Read more: Orange Botswana CEO, Nene Maïga, Wins Female Innovator of the Year Award 
  • Govt’s P1.4billion Tati land headacheNovember 23, 2023
    BAKANG TIRO editors@thepatriot.co.bw The 45 000 hectares of land recently acquired by Botswana government from Tati Company to the tune of P1.4 billion, will address acute land shortage in Northeast district, the Minister of Lands and Water Affairs (ML&WA),… Read more: Govt’s P1.4billion Tati land headache
The Patriot On Sunday

© 2022 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders

© 2022 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?