• Mining sector endures worst recessionMay 27, 2025
    Mining shows zero confidence on better business conditions Weaker global demand of rough diamonds trouble the sector Other sectors optimistic about improved conditions in 2025   BAKANG TIRO RelatedPosts Mining sector endures worst recession Who is the PSP PROTECTING?… Read more: Mining sector endures worst recession
  • Who is the PSP PROTECTING?May 27, 2025
    “She is protecting those facing corruption probe, hence removing DCEC intelligence head”- claim The DCEC recently confirmed that it was investigating some senior govt officials   DITIRO MOTLHABANE RelatedPosts Mining sector endures worst recession Who is the PSP PROTECTING?… Read more: Who is the PSP PROTECTING?
  • TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding SolutionsMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
  • WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance MangerMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
  • MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge BusinessMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
  • Login
  • Register
Sunday, June 1, 2025
-6 °c
Columbus
6 ° Sat
13 ° Sun
15 ° Mon
16 ° Tue
The Patriot On Sunday
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
Cart / $0.00

No products in the cart.

  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders
No Result
View All Result
The Patriot On Sunday
No Result
View All Result
Home News

‘Butterfly’ acquital reversed

Ricardo Kanono by Ricardo Kanono
August 11, 2022
in News
245
0
Maswabi

Maswabi

491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
ShareShareShare

THABO BAGWASI

editors@thepatriot.co.bw

RelatedPosts

Who is the PSP PROTECTING?

BDP shakes BPF

Civil Service salary talks begin

A full bench of the Court of Appeal (CoA) on Friday morning unanimously thwacked and set-aside a series of orders by Justice Dr Zein Kebonang, made in favour of Welhemina Maswabi, a former spy in the Directorate of Intelligence and Security Services (DIS).  The full bench, made up of President of the Court of Appeal (CoA) Justice Tebogo Tau, together with Chief Justice Terence Rannowane, Justices Isaac Lesetedi, Singh Walia and Tshepo Motswagole quashed a ruling made by Dr Kebonang on the 23rd of August 2021. Justice Dr Kebonang had ruled that the DPP had failed to adduce evidence against Maswabi and therefore reviewed and set aside its decision to prosecute the suspended intelligence agent.

The Directorate of Public Prosecutions (DPP) succesfully argued that Justice Dr Kebonang erred in law when determining that there was a decision to review when such had been withdrawn, erred in misdirecting himself that the DPP’s decision to prosecute is reviewable in circumstances of the Maswabi case and in determining criminal proceedings that were not before his court. In addition, the DPP believed Justice Dr Kebonang made orders beyond the purview of review proceedings.

Maswabi whose arrest made screaming headlines in 2019, used to navigate the theater of intelligence espionage under the codename Butterfly. She  was initially charged with financing terrorism, possession of unexplained assets and wealth, and false declaration of a passport. The financing of terrorism charge was later withdrawn by the DPP after it failed to gather sufficient evidence against Maswabi.

The full CoA bench dismissed the ruling and the orders contained therein as incompetent and erroneous. Justice Tau also determined that section 150(4) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act also does not confer any power on the High Court to acquit Maswabi on any charge where she had not taken a plea. “On the basis of the foregoing, it was incompetent for the High Court to acquit Maswabi on all charges levelled against her,” reads the judgment in part.

Furthermore, Justice Tau found judge Dr Kebonang to have overreached himself by revisiting and making inferences with regards to a charge of financing terrorism which had been withdrawn by the Directorate of Public Prosecutions (DPP) at the Broadhurst Magistrate Court, long before the case landed in his chambers.

The CoA also set aside Dr Kebonang’s decision to refer the Director of DPP Stephen Tiroyakgosi, Lead Investigator Jako Hubona and the then Principal Prosecutor Priscilla Israel to their superiors for disciplinary action and punishment as inappropriate since the trio were never  availed the opportunity to address the platform where the issue was raised. “On the issue of referrals of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), the Investigator and Prosecuting Counsel, to the supervisors and or higher authorities to carry out further investigations, disciplinary hearings and administer sanctions were appropriate,  Counsel for the respondent conceded that it was improper for the court to issue an order without affording the parties an opportunity to address it where such an issue  was raised mero muto(of one’s volition),” reads part of the CoA judgment.

Some of DPP’s prayers which won over the CoA was its petition to determine that Justice Dr Kebonang had misdirected himself in his finding that there was a decision to review when such a decision had been withdrawn and further that he had misdirected himself in finding that the DPP’s decision to prosecute Maswabi was reviewable in the current circumstances or at all. The DPP had also wanted the CoA to determine further that Justice Dr Kebonang had misdirected himself by ordering Maswabi’s acquittal and discharge even though she had never entered any plea to the charges before him or any other competent court for that matter.

It had further wanted the apex court to declare that Justice Dr Kebonang had erred and misdirected himself by making findings that are criminal in nature and beyond the ambit of the review proceedings before him and furthermore in his misdirection’s by interfering and overruling DPP Director Tiroyakgosi by withdrawing criminal charges against Maswabi, contrary to constitutional statutes.

DPP had also wanted the CoA to declare that Justice Dr Kebonang had erred in law by making orders that are incompetent and beyond the purview of the review proceedings with particular reference to Maswabi’s acquittal while she never entered a plea and his suggestion of sanction for DPP head honchos.

It remains to be seen if the DPP will resume judicial proceedings against Maswabi who the state accuses of unexplained property contrary to Section 34 (1) (b) of the Corruption and Economic Crime Act, and False declaration of a passport which contravenes Section 315 of the Penal Code.

The DPP was represented by Akoonyatse Attorneys while Maswabi was represented by veteran criminal lawyer Unoda Mack and Victor Ramalepa.

Related

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Mosadi Tota powers women in business

Next Post

MY PRESIDENT IS CLUELESS

Related Posts

Who is the PSP PROTECTING?
News

Who is the PSP PROTECTING?

May 27, 2025
BDP shakes BPF
News

BDP shakes BPF

May 26, 2025
Civil Service salary talks begin
News

Civil Service salary talks begin

May 19, 2025
Mine workers blast Boko
News

Mine workers blast Boko

May 19, 2025
Khama pokes Motshegwa
News

Khama pokes Motshegwa

May 13, 2025
Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity
News

Europe Day 2025 – Celebrating 75 Years of Unity and Solidarity

May 12, 2025
Next Post
MY PRESIDENT IS CLUELESS

MY PRESIDENT IS CLUELESS

Please login to join discussion
  • Mining sector endures worst recessionMay 27, 2025
    Mining shows zero confidence on better business conditions Weaker global demand of rough diamonds trouble the sector Other sectors optimistic about improved conditions in 2025   BAKANG TIRO RelatedPosts Mining sector endures worst recession Who is the PSP PROTECTING?… Read more: Mining sector endures worst recession
  • Who is the PSP PROTECTING?May 27, 2025
    “She is protecting those facing corruption probe, hence removing DCEC intelligence head”- claim The DCEC recently confirmed that it was investigating some senior govt officials   DITIRO MOTLHABANE RelatedPosts Mining sector endures worst recession Who is the PSP PROTECTING?… Read more: Who is the PSP PROTECTING?
  • TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding SolutionsMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
  • WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance MangerMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
  • MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge BusinessMay 26, 2025
    RelatedPosts TIKI MEDIA * Head Branding Solutions WILDERNESS AIR * Quality Assurance Manger MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS AND INNOVATION * Deputy Director – Department of Shared Digital Services * Director – Research and Knowledge Business
The Patriot On Sunday

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Sport
  • Analysis & Opinions
  • Vacancies & Tenders

© 2024 Copyright The Patriot On Sunday - Inspired by Search Mart.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?